Curious Boundary

The Only Tie in Test Cricket History: How Sport’s Rarest Finish Happened at Brisbane in 1960

Written by

Curious Boundary

in

, ,
⚡ Just give me the answer

The short answer: On 14 December 1960, Australia and West Indies tied their Test at Brisbane—the first tie in 148 years of Test cricket. Australia needed 233 to win, collapsed to 92 for 6, then recovered through a 134-run partnership between Richie Benaud and Alan Davidson, only to lose Ian Meckiff to a run-out from Joe Solomon's direct hit with the scores level. Only one other tie has occurred in Test cricket since.

Want the interesting bit? Keep reading ↓

On the final afternoon of the first Test at Brisbane’s Gabba on 14 December 1960, Test cricket witnessed an outcome so rare that it would not happen again for another 26 years. Australia and West Indies ended their match with identical scores—each team having completed their innings—making the Tied Test the first, and still one of only two, such results in 148 years of the sport’s oldest format.

It was not a draw. A draw requires the batting side to refuse a result; a tie demands equal runs and a completed fourth innings. The statistical improbability is matched only by the drama that preceded it: a West Indies team that looked destined for victory, an Australian collapse, a miraculous recovery, and a run-out that sealed the impossible on the final ball.

The Setup: A Series Turned Upside Down

The West Indies arrived in Australia for their first tour in December 1960 under Frank Worrell’s captaincy—itself a watershed moment in Caribbean cricket, as all previous West Indies captains had been white. They batted first and totalled 453, built on centuries from Garry Sobers (132) and contributions from Frank Worrell (65) and Joe Solomon (65). Australia replied with 505, anchored by Norm O’Neill’s 181 and Bob Simpson’s 92.

The West Indies’ second innings yielded 284, setting Australia a target of 233. On paper, it was eminently achievable. In practice, it became a chase that defied probability.

Collapse and Counter-Attack

Wes Hall’s pace bowling decimated Australia’s middle order in the second innings. By the time Australia had reached 92 for 6, the West Indies seemed certain victors. The home team was crumbling, and there appeared no path to the required runs.

Then came one of cricket’s great recoveries. Richie Benaud and Alan Davidson engineered a 134-run partnership that tilted the entire match towards Australia. The momentum swung so decisively that, with two balls remaining, the West Indies faced the genuine prospect of defeat.

But Test cricket rarely offers safe resolutions, especially when so much drama remains.

The Final Over: When All Outcomes Were Possible

As the final over commenced, the scores were level. Both outcomes—an Australian victory or a West Indies win—remained mathematically possible within the space of a handful of deliveries. Such was the compression of possibility that, in the minutes before the end, a draw or even a tie had entered the conversation alongside the conventional results.

Ian Meckiff was run out from Joe Solomon’s direct hit from square-leg on a ball that left the scores exactly level. The fourth innings was complete, and neither team had secured victory. Test cricket’s first tie had occurred.

Legacy and Rarity

Only one other tied Test has occurred since December 1960—a 26-year gap that emphasises the rarity of the outcome. Of the more than 2,570 Tests played since 1877, a tied result remains an extreme outlier, a reminder of how seldom cricket’s mathematics align so perfectly and how unusual it is for a result to hang on a single dismissal in the final moments of play.

The West Indies lost the series 2–1, but the tour galvanised cricket in Australia. The team was paraded through Melbourne in open-top cars on 17 February 1961 to crowds that reflected their popularity and the excitement they had generated. Frank Worrell’s captaincy and the team’s attacking cricket—embodied by Sobers’ stroke-play and the pace of Wes Hall—captured Australian hearts and helped revitalise interest in international Test cricket at a time when the format needed oxygen.

The Tied Test of Brisbane 1960 remains the most compelling argument for why Test cricket, at its finest, can compress an entire psychological journey—hope, despair, defiance, and heartbreak—into five days and a single, unforgettable run-out.

Sources

More posts